Subjectivity in sports: a necessary evil
The Olympics were abuzz with concerns over incomplete hotel rooms, snowflakes that don’t open or most importantly subjectivity in judging.
The controversy over the Sochi Olympics judging hit its climax in the female figure skating competition between Kim Yu-na of Korea and Adelina Sotnikova of Russia.
Although less than half a point separated the two skaters going into the long program and both skated excellent programs, Sotnikova won gold by 5.48 points.
Watchers were astonished that both performances that were so evenly matched in difficulty and finesse were rewarded such different scores.
Immediately the event was cast into outrage and plagued with opinion.
The Olympic-sized obstacle brought into question the influence of subjectivity in sports.
Analysts have been looking into ways to limit subjectivity in scoring, while others have called to increase transparency in the scoring system.
My first response, to quote John Stossel, is “give me a break.”
Regardless of the attempts to solve back for bias, subjectivity is a way of life and certainly is nothing new.
Furthermore, when it comes to a judged contest, there is always one person who feels they have been cheated (usually the loser).
In many respects, subjectivity can be a compliment to the sport. Sometimes it is the only way that sport can function.
Subjectivity in the snowboarding half-pipe has allowed room for the sport to evolve.
Contestants are encouraged to push the limits and throw new tricks. Judges are instructed to reward this ambition with higher scores, and for the most part they do.
Figure skating without judging would be like a hockey game without a puck.
Although judges may not be perfect, without them the sport would just be a pretty skating routine.
Even in sports without secretive modes of scoring such as football, there is room for human error and subjectivity.
If you don’t believe me, ask the Packers if they should have lost their game to the Seahawks during the NFL referee lockout.
Even the replay could not correct one of the worst calls in the history of the sport.
A more recent example was the Canadian Women’s goal scored against the U.S. in a preliminary round in Sochi.
Although the whistle supposedly sounded, the goal counted.
As a collegiate debater I have come to understand and deal with subjectivity in sport.
Judge subjectivity is literally built into the some of the events we compete in.
Although nearly every judge will claim to be “tabula rasa” or a blank slate, it is easier said than done.
As a competitor, I am forced to either let myself be hurt by this or use it to my advantage.
Even if a judge was able to leave all of their experience and opinions at the door, there is still subjectivity in evaluating arguments.
It is the competitors’ responsibility to find out what arguments the judge prefers.
If you can’t handle subjectivity in judging, the easiest thing to do is not compete.
When it comes to controversy in judging, what can’t be fixed must be worked with.
For figure skaters the controversy over judging attracted a lot of viewers to their sport. Let’s just hope the sport can handle a little subjectivity.
Get Top Stories Delivered Weekly
From Around the Web
More ASU Herald News Articles
Recent ASU Herald News Articles
Discuss This Article
MOST POPULAR ASU HERALD NEWS
GET TOP STORIES DELIVERED WEEKLY
FOLLOW OUR NEWSPAPER
LATEST ASU HERALD NEWS
FROM AROUND THE WEB
- Got a Headache? Manage it With Chiropractic Care
- 3 Pescadores Rescatados en el Mar gracias a Dispositivo GPS
- When It Comes to Winter Roof Checkups, the Attic Is Your...
- Is It Time to Sell Your Structured Settlement for Cash?
- Pest Proof Now to Protect Homes for Winter
- 3 Fishermen Rescued at Sea Thanks to GPS Device
- Mes de la Hispanidad inspira liderazgo, empoderamiento,...
- Majority of Moms and Moms-to-Be Believe in Public...
- Wineries Speak Up About the Benefits of Using Natural Cork
- Taking a Holistic Approach to Fit Living
COLLEGE PRESS RELEASES
- Over 2,000 Groups Prepare to “Hit the Streets” with Volunteers and Celebrities for National Voter Registration Day on September 23, 2014
- Peace Corps Director Calls on College Students to Make a Difference After Graduation Through International Service
- USA NETWORK AND VERIZON LAUNCH THE “CHARACTERS UNITE COLLEGE TOUR” COMPETITION FOR STUDENTS TO BRING A USA NETWORK CELEBRITY AND A WORTHY CAUSE TO THEIR CAMPUS
- WHEN GEORGIA SMILED: THE ROBIN MCGRAW REVELATION FOUNDATION TEAMS WITH PIVOT AND STUDENTS OF THE WORLD TO LAUNCH THE #iASPIRE GRANT CONTEST
- Latino Groups Launch National Campaign to Deliver Record Latino Turnout for 2014 Midterm Elections